In October 2024, the Law Commission published a consultation paper as part of their review of the laws governing social care for disabled children in England. The Law Commission aim to make recommendations that ensure that the social care framework it is fairer and simpler for disabled children, and that it is up to date. The consultation period ran until January 2025 and today (16 September 2025), the Law Commission have shared their final recommendations to modernise the fragmented legal framework governing social care for disabled children. The full report and recommendations are now with the government for their consideration.
Prior to the development and launch of the consultation paper, the Down’s Syndrome Association arranged for a small group of parents to meet with the Law Commission review team, which helped inform their planning and proposals for the review. Once the consultation paper was published, we co-ordinated a further focus group meeting with parents and we also submitted a written response to the consultation questions.
In our response we highlighted:
- the need for adequate funding and workforce training, including how to assess and support children and young people who have learning disabilities, including those who have Down’s syndrome
- the issues faced by families in securing social care assessments for children who have Down’s syndrome and how complex the system is to navigate
- a postcode lottery, where families in different areas have access to different levels of support
- a lack of person-centred assessments and adapted assessment processes that are based on ability rather than age
- poor preparation for adulthood, with transition planning often starting too late
- the need for greater accountability and simpler routes of redress.
In the report published today, The Law Commission recommends keeping disabled children within existing Children Act protections while introducing a discrete set of rights and entitlements for disabled children into that Act. In introducing their recommendations, they have provided the following caveat, which explains why they have not included all the provisional proposals set out in the consultation paper in their final recommendations:
‘In this report we have tried to balance these views to identify workable recommendations to simplify, clarify and modernise disabled children’s social care law, and ensure it is fit for purpose.’
The Down’s Syndrome Association welcomes many of the final recommendations, which will hopefully improve access to social care support for children and young people who have Down’s syndrome, including:
- a single statutory duty to assess the social care needs of disabled children, which arises when a child is disabled and may have needs for care and support arising from their disability
- the recommendation for there to be national eligibility criteria for children’s social care, to hopefully end the postcode lottery
- the requirement for an assessor to have skills, knowledge and competence, as well as appropriate training to undertake assessments of disabled children
- the additional requirement to consult a person who has expertise in the child’s condition, if the child’s needs require it
- the recognition of the specialist knowledge that parents have on their child’s needs and condition
- the recognition of the specific needs of siblings of disabled children
- the assessment of a disabled child’s need for Adult Social care support to begin by the school year in which the child turns 14, or earlier if appropriate.
However, we note with disappointment that no recommendation has been made for more comprehensive legislative reform, which would assist families in navigating the social care legislative system. This decision falls short of the reform needed to make the law clearer and more accessible, and we believe that statutory guidance alone is insufficient to bring about the necessary changes.
In the proposals consulted on, the Law Commission suggested a provisional proposal for disabled children to be taken out of the scope of s17 of the Children Act 1989, and for there to be a new simplified and unified legal framework for assessing the needs of disabled children, similar to the Care Act 2014. At the Down’s Syndrome Association, we know from families how complex the current legislative framework is to understand and navigate, and we had welcomed this proposal.
Despite the majority of consultation responses agreeing with this proposal, which would have made the law clearer and more accessible, the Law Commission has decided not to include this within their final recommendations, and instead have recommended that additional provisions are introduced into the Children Act 1989, and that there should be new dedicated statutory guidance that helps local authorities ‘ensure that there is an appropriate balance struck between identifying and meeting the needs of disabled children and their families in a non-stigmatising way and safeguarding them from harm and abuse’.
The withdrawal of the proposed recommendation is deeply disappointing. It is likely that many parents and carers who took part in the events we organised and who responded to the consultation directly will also be disappointed and will feel that the recommendations do not go far enough to simplify the process and that additional provisions within existing legislation and the introduction of statutory guidance alone is insufficient to bring the reform that is required.
It remains essential for the government to allocate sufficient funding to children’s social care services, ensuring that the needs of disabled children and their families are met. Adequate support should be accessible to families caring for a disabled child, without requiring them to navigate a complex framework comprising multiple legislative provisions.
16 September 2025
Read more Policy and Campaigns news and blogs or sign up for our newsletter for weekly updates from the DSA.
