DSA Response to the Timms Review Interim Report on the Personal Independence Payment System

The Down’s Syndrome Association (DSA) welcomes the publication of the Timms Review’s interim report and its recognition that too many disabled people experience the current Personal Independence Payment (PIP) system as stressful, inconsistent and badly administered.

For people who have Down’s syndrome, PIP is a vital non-means-tested benefit that helps meet the lifelong additional costs of disability and supports independence, health and participation in everyday life. There are misconceptions that it has become an alternative to employment, which is not the case. Many of the people we work with are working alongside receiving PIP as a way of enabling them to live the ordinary lives they wish for.

PIP is particularly important for people who have Down’s syndrome living in residential care (who only receive the mobility component) or supported living settings. Without access to PIP, many people would be restricted to a basic existence that does not reflect their age, aspirations or right to participation.

Any reform that weakens PIP’s role in meeting these additional costs would have a disproportionate impact on people who have Down’s syndrome living outside the family home, where alternative sources of flexible personal income are extremely limited.

Our evidence to the Review shows that the greatest challenge is not necessarily the design of PIP itself, but how it is applied in practice.

The DSA helped shape the development of the PIP questions, and we are clear that the core structure does not need rewriting as they already considered concerns around prompting, supervision and cognitive impairment. Our experience has been that too often assessments fail to recognise the importance of lifelong supervision. Reopening or redesigning the core questions could risk inadvertently disadvantaging people who have Down’s syndrome, whose needs are lifelong, and often misunderstood. Instead, the priority should be to support the assessors to extract realistic and contextual information from families.

The DSA strongly objects to any shift, whether explicit or indirect, towards mean-testing. This overlooks the reality that for people who have Down’s syndrome, disability-related costs are lifelong and cumulative. They arise across daily living rather than in one single area, and they exist regardless of household income. Any move towards means testing would fundamentally misunderstand the nature of disability-related expenditure and would risk shifting costs onto families, local authorities and the NHS.

As the Review develops its final recommendations, it will be important that reforms designed to improve the experience of some claimant groups do not unintentionally disadvantage people with lifelong learning disabilities. Changes to assessment criteria or descriptors must be carefully tested to ensure they continue to recognise the needs of people who have Down’s syndrome and other lifelong intellectual disabilities.

We look forward to continuing to work with the Review team to help develop a system that is fairer, more consistent and gives people confidence that their needs will be properly understood.


 

A young man who has Down's syndrome works in a kitchen making flat breads. He is wearing kitchen uniform and gloves, and is working with a kitchen mixer. Text reads: Claiming Personal Independence Payment (PIP) from age 16. Also the Down's Syndrome Association logo.Click here to access our resource on PIP from age 16.
The whole application process is covered, including challenging decisions and how PIP affects other benefits.

If you have questions or concerns, contact the DSA Helpline’s Benefits Adviser.

Monday & Thursday 10am-4pm, Tues & Weds 10am-12.30pm
Telephone: 0333 1212 300
Email: helen.wild@downs-syndrome.org.uk