Understanding your rights in Direct Payments

A Plain English Guide for the Families of People who have Down’s Syndrome

March 2025

Introduction

What are Direct Payments?

Direct Payments are money given to you (or your family) by your local council so that you can arrange your own care and support. Instead of the council choosing your carers or services, you get the money to spend in a way that works best for you. This means you can choose the people who support you, when and how they provide support, and where you receive it. It gives you and your family more control over your daily life and care decisions.

Direct Payments can be used for a variety of services, such as:

  • Employing personal assistants to help with everyday tasks.
  • Paying for community activities that support your well-being.
  • Buying specialist equipment or services that meet your needs.

However, councils have rules about how Direct Payments should be spent, and sometimes they ask people to pay money back. Understanding these rules can help you make the best decisions about your care.

Why is this Guide Important?

Some councils do not always follow the law when they ask people to repay Direct Payments or when they decide how much money people should get. This can lead to confusion, stress, and even financial hardship for families who rely on this funding for essential support.

In some cases, councils have asked for repayments without properly explaining why. Others have set budgets too low, making it difficult for people to afford the care they need.

This guide explains your rights and what to do if you think the council has made a mistake. It will help you:

  • Understand what Direct Payments can be used for.
  • Recognise when a council’s decision might be unfair.
  • Take action if you are asked to repay money unfairly.
  • Know where to turn for help and advice.

Key Legal Protections

The law that protects your rights when you get Direct Payments is called the Care Act 2014. It says:

  • You should have choice and control over your care and support.
  • Your personal budget must be enough to meet your assessed needs.
  • Councils must make decisions that are fair and reasonable.
  • If the council wants you to repay money, they must give you a fair chance to explain how you used it.

The Care Act is designed to ensure that people with disabilities, including those with Down’s Syndrome, have the right to live as independently as possible. It recognises that everyone has different needs and that care should be flexible to support those needs.

When Can Councils Ask for Repayment of Direct Payments?

Direct Payments give you flexibility and control over your care, but councils can sometimes ask for money back. However, they must follow the law and treat each case fairly.

Councils cannot take money back just because you have some left in your account. They must prove why repayment is necessary and give you a fair chance to explain how the money has been used or will be used.

When Repayment May Be Lawful

There are only a few situations where a council can lawfully ask you to repay Direct Payments:

  • Money Not Used to Meet Assessed Needs
    • Direct Payments must be used for the care and support outlined in your Care and Support Plan.
    • If the money was spent on something completely unrelated, the council may ask for repayment.
  • Overpayments by the Council
    • If the council made a mistake and paid too much into your account, they can ask for the extra money back.
    • They must explain the overpayment and allow reasonable time to repay.
  • Fraud or Misuse
    • If someone deliberately misuses the funds, such as spending them on something that has no connection to care, the council has the right to ask for repayment.
    • In serious cases, councils might stop future Direct Payments or take legal action.
  • Care and Support Needs Have Changed
    • If your care needs significantly decrease and the council has not adjusted your budget, they may ask for repayment of any unused surplus that is no longer required.
    • The council must conduct a proper reassessment before making a repayment demand.
  • Funds No Longer Needed Due to a Change in Circumstances
    • If a person receiving Direct Payments moves into residential care or passes away, unused funds may need to be returned.
    • The council must take into account outstanding expenses, such as unpaid invoices for care already provided.

 

When Repayment is Unlawful

Some councils apply blanket policies that automatically reclaim any money left in an account without considering the person’s needs. These policies are illegal because the Care Act 2014 requires councils to assess individual circumstances.

  • Blanket Policies on “Surplus” Funds
    • Some councils wrongly reclaim any funds left in an account at the end of the month or year. This is unlawful unless they prove the money is not needed.
    • People often save up Direct Payments for future care costs, such as respite care, equipment, or hiring a new personal assistant. The council must allow for this kind of planned spending.
  • Demanding Repayment Without Proper Evidence
    • The council must explain in writing why they are asking for repayment.
    • They cannot just state that a person has too much money in their account. They must show why the money is not needed.
  • Ignoring the Right to a Fair Process
    • If the council decides to take money back, they must:
      • Give a clear explanation of why they are reclaiming funds.
      • Give the person, or their representative, time to respond and provide evidence.
      • Consider why the money has not yet been spent, for example, delays in finding a new care worker.
    • If they fail to do this, their demand is unlawful and can be challenged.

 

What to Do If You Receive a Repayment Request

If you receive a letter from the council asking for repayment, you should:

  • Step 1: Ask for a Written Explanation
    • Request a breakdown of why they believe repayment is necessary.
    • Check whether they have followed the law and whether they have given you a chance to explain how the money is being used.
  • Step 2: Gather Evidence
    • Show records of how the money has been used or why it has not yet been spent.
    • Provide receipts, bank statements, or a written statement explaining how the money is needed for future care costs.
  • Step 3: Challenge the Decision
    • If the request seems unfair or unlawful, you have the right to challenge it.
    • You can:
      • Write a formal complaint to the council.
      • Ask for an independent review of the decision.
      • Seek advocacy support to help argue your case.
      • If the council refuses to reconsider, you can escalate the issue to the Local Government Ombudsman or seek legal advice.

 

Key Takeaways

  • Councils must not apply blanket repayment policies.
  • You have the right to keep funds if they are being saved for future care.
  • Councils must provide evidence and follow fair processes before demanding repayment.
  • If you receive an unfair repayment request, challenge it and seek support.

 

How Councils Must Decide How Much Money You Get

When the council gives you Direct Payments, the amount must be enough to meet your assessed care and support needs. This is a legal requirement under the Care Act 2014, and councils must not set budgets too low based on cost-saving priorities.

Many people experience unfair reductions in their personal budgets or are told that their Direct Payment should only cover minimum wage for personal assistants. These practices are unlawful if they do not ensure that your needs are fully met.

This section explains how councils should decide your budget, what they can and cannot do, and what steps you can take if your budget is too low.

 

Legal requirements for setting your budget

Under the Care Act 2014, councils must set a Personal Budget that is sufficient to meet your assessed needs. This is covered by:

  • Section 26, Care Act 2014 – Personal Budgets must reflect the cost of meeting all eligible needs as agreed in your Care and Support Plan.
  • Care and Support Statutory Guidance, Paragraph 11.10 – Budgets must be accurate, sufficient, and based on individual needs, not a standard formula.
  • Care and Support Statutory Guidance, Paragraph 12.25 – Direct Payments must allow flexibility and personalisation while remaining sufficient to meet assessed needs.

 

How the Council Should Calculate Your Direct Payment

The amount of Direct Payments you receive should be based on a realistic assessment of what is needed to arrange and pay for the care and support agreed in your plan.

Key Factors That Should Be Considered

When calculating your Personal Budget, the council must take into account:

  • The actual cost of care in your local area
    Councils cannot just assume a national or fixed cost for care; they must look at market rates where you live.
  • The number of support hours you need
    Your budget must match the support hours identified in your care plan.
  • Pay rates for Personal Assistants (PAs) or care providers
    • Many councils base budgets on minimum wage, but if it is not possible to recruit PAs at that rate, they must adjust the budget accordingly.
    • Councils must also consider whether higher pay is needed to attract experienced carers or support specialist needs.
  • Employment-related costs
    If you employ a PA, your Direct Payment must also cover:
    • Employer National Insurance contributions
    • Holiday pay, sick pay, and pension contributions
    • Recruitment and training costs
    • Insurance for employing staff
  • Travel and transport costs
    If your care requires travel (e.g., a PA taking you to medical appointments, social activities, or work), these costs must be included.
  • Specialist support needs
    If you need carers with specific training (e.g., supporting complex health needs or behavioural issues), the council must ensure the budget covers the higher cost of trained professionals.
  • Respite care and contingency planning
    If your family provides unpaid care, your budget should include funding for respite care to prevent burnout.

 

What Councils Cannot Do

Set Budgets Based on Cost-Saving Rather Than Need

  • Councils must base your budget on assessed needs, not on financial pressures or a standard formula.
  • It is unlawful to offer a budget that is too low to pay for the care you need.

Insist That PAs Are Paid Minimum Wage

  • Councils cannot force you to pay your PA minimum wage if higher pay is required to recruit and retain skilled support staff.
  • If PAs in your area typically earn a higher rate, your budget must reflect that.

Apply a “One-Size-Fits-All” Budget Calculation

  • Personal Budgets must be individual – A council cannot say that all Direct Payment recipients receive a set amount without looking at their specific needs.
  • The High Court ruled in the Lancashire County Council case (2025) that councils must assess personal circumstances rather than applying a fixed policy.

Set Budgets Without Proper Explanation

  • The council must provide a detailed breakdown of how they have calculated your budget.
  • If you ask, they must show:
    • The hourly rates they have used for PAs or care providers.
    • Any additional allowances for expenses like training, recruitment, or contingency funds.

What to do if your budget is too low

If you believe your budget is too low to meet your needs, you have the right to challenge it.

Step 1: Request a Breakdown of Your Budget

  • Ask the council for a full written explanation of how they calculated your budget.
  • Request details of:
    • Hourly care costs used in their calculations.
    • Assumptions made about your care needs.
    • Any deductions applied (e.g., assumed family support).

Step 2: Gather Evidence

  • Get quotes from local care providers or PA agencies to show the real cost of care in your area.
  • If you need to pay your PA more than the council suggests, show evidence of local pay rates.
  • If there are travel, training, or employment-related costs, document these expenses.

Step 3: Request a Formal Review

  • If the budget is too low, ask for a reassessment of your care needs and personal budget.
  • Councils must review Personal Budgets when requested under Section 27, Care Act 2014.

Step 4: Challenge the Decision

  • If the council refuses to increase your budget:
    • Make a formal complaint to the council.
    • Highlight the legal duty to provide sufficient funding under the Care Act 2014.
    • Refer to the Lancashire County Council ruling (2025), which confirmed that underfunding Direct Payments is unlawful.

Step 5: Escalate If Necessary

If the council does not resolve the issue, you can:

  • Take the complaint to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman.
  • Seek legal advice and consider a judicial review if your budget does not meet your assessed needs.

 

Key Takeaways

  • Your Personal Budget must be enough to meet your assessed care needs.
  • Councils cannot set a budget too low just to save money.
  • You have the right to request a breakdown of how your budget is calculated.
  • If your budget is too low, you can challenge the decision and ask for a reassessment.
  • The Lancashire ruling confirmed that budgets must be based on real costs, not arbitrary policies.

 

How to Challenge an Unfair Decision

If you believe the council has made an unfair decision about your Direct Payments, you have the right to challenge it. This applies to decisions about:

  • A demand for repayment that you believe is unjustified.
  • A Personal Budget that is too low to meet your assessed needs.
  • Refusal to fund certain care arrangements that are necessary for your well-being.
  • Delays in reviewing or reassessing your needs, resulting in an outdated or insufficient budget.
  • A council policy that does not consider individual circumstances, such as automatically reducing budgets or reclaiming funds.

Under the Care Act 2014, councils must make fair, reasonable, and evidence-based decisions. This section explains how to challenge an unfair decision and what steps to take if the council refuses to change its position.

Legal Rights When Challenging a Council Decision

The Care Act 2014 provides strong legal protections to ensure that individuals receiving Direct Payments are treated fairly.

  • Section 26, Care Act 2014
    A Personal Budget must reflect the actual cost of meeting a person’s assessed needs.
  • Section 27, Care Act 2014
    If a person’s needs change, their budget must be reviewed and updated.
  • Section 33(5), Care Act 2014
    Councils can only reclaim Direct Payments if a condition has been breached; they cannot reclaim funds just because they are unspent.
  • Article 6, Human Rights Act 1998
    The right to a fair process before financial penalties or reductions are imposed.

Key takeaway:

If the council has made a decision without properly considering your individual circumstances or legal rights, you can challenge it through a formal process.

 

First Steps: Requesting a Review

Before making a formal complaint, it is best to try to resolve the issue informally by asking the council to review the decision.

Step 1: Request a Written Explanation

  • Ask for a detailed written explanation of the decision.
  • Request a breakdown of calculations used to determine your budget.
  • If it is a repayment request, ask for evidence of why the funds must be repaid.

Step 2: Gather Evidence

  • Keep records of how the money has been used, including receipts, invoices, and bank statements.
  • If your care costs are higher than the council allows, collect quotes from care providers to prove the real cost of support.
  • If the council claims funds are “surplus”, provide evidence that the money is planned for future care (e.g., respite, PA wages, equipment).

Step 3: Request a Reassessment

  • If your Personal Budget is too low, formally request a review under Section 27 of the Care Act.
  • The council must review your care plan whenever there is a significant change in your needs.

 

Making a Formal Complaint

If the council refuses to change its decision after a review, you can submit a formal complaint.

How to Submit a Complaint

  • Write a complaint letter or email to the council’s Adult Social Care complaints team.
  • Clearly explain the issue, including:
    • The decision being challenged.
    • Why you believe it is unfair or unlawful.
    • Evidence supporting your case.
    • A request for the decision to be reconsidered.
  • Request a response within a set timeframe (eg 21 days).

Most councils must respond within 20 working days. If they refuse to reconsider, you can escalate the complaint further.

 

Escalating the Complaint

If the council does not resolve the issue, you have the right to take further action.

Option 1: Contact the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman (LGSCO)

  • The LGSCO investigates complaints about unfair social care decisions.
  • They can force the council to reconsider decisions and issue compensation.
  • You must go through the council’s complaints process first before contacting the Ombudsman.

Option 2: Seek Legal Advice

  • If your budget is too low or the council is demanding repayment unfairly, you can get legal advice from a solicitor or advocacy group.
  • If necessary, judicial review can be used to challenge unlawful decisions.

Option 3: Advocacy and Public Pressure

  • Many councils reverse decisions when challenged by advocacy organisations or local MPs.
  • You can contact a disability rights organisation to support your complaint.

 

Case Study: Challenging an Unfair Budget Reduction

Background

David, a 35-year-old man who has Down’s Syndrome, had a Personal Budget of £22,000 per year for his care. The council reduced his budget to £15,000 without reassessing his needs, claiming it was due to “cost efficiency measures.”

Challenge Process

  • David’s family requested a reassessment under Section 27 of the Care Act.
  • They provided evidence that the new budget was too low to pay for his care package, including PA wages, travel expenses, and social activities.
  • The council initially refused to change the budget, so the family submitted a formal complaint.

Outcome

  • The council admitted it had applied a blanket policy rather than assessing David’s individual needs.
  • His budget was reinstated, and the council committed to reviewing its budget-setting process.

Lesson

Councils must assess individual needs rather than cutting budgets based on financial targets. If your budget is reduced unfairly, challenge it using legal protections under the Care Act 2014.

 

Key Takeaways

  • You have the right to challenge unfair Direct Payment decisions.
  • Always request a written explanation and evidence for repayment demands or budget reductions.
  • Gather evidence to support your case, such as invoices, care provider quotes, and planned spending.
  • If a decision is unfair, ask for a reassessment under Section 27 of the Care Act.
  • If the council refuses to reconsider, submit a formal complaint.
  • Escalate the issue to the Local Government Ombudsman or seek legal advice if needed.

 

Where to get help and support

Challenging a Direct Payments decision can feel overwhelming, but you do not have to do it alone. There are several organisations, legal services, and advocacy groups that can support you in understanding your rights, gathering evidence, and making a formal challenge.

This section outlines where to find help, including advocacy services, complaint procedures, legal advice, and independent investigations.

 

Key advocacy organisations

Local Advocacy Services

  • Many local authorities fund independent advocacy services for people who need support with social care decisions.
  • Contact your local council and ask for a list of approved advocacy providers.

Down’s Syndrome Association (DSA)

Provides tailored advice and resources for individuals who have Down’s Syndrome and their families.

POhWER

A national advocacy service offering free, independent support for people facing issues with social care.

VoiceAbility

Provides support for people challenging social care decisions, including Direct Payments and Personal Budgets.

Citizens Advice

Offers free legal guidance on social care rights and how to challenge unfair decisions.

Local Carers Centres

If you are a family member or carer, local carers centres can help you advocate for the person receiving Direct Payments.

 

Formal complaints process

If you disagree with the council’s decision about Direct Payments, you have the right to make a formal complaint.

Step 1: Use the Council’s Complaints Procedure

  • Every local council has a social care complaints process.
  • Search for “[Your Local Authority] Adult Social Care Complaints” online to find the correct procedure.
  • Complaints should be made in writing and include:
    • A clear explanation of the issue.
    • Evidence (such as care plans, financial statements, and quotes from care providers).
    • A request for a review of the decision.

Step 2: Escalate to the Local Government Ombudsman (LGSCO)

  • If the council does not resolve your complaint, you can escalate it to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman.
  • The LGSCO can investigate unfair treatment, incorrect repayment demands, and insufficient Personal Budgets.

 

Seeking legal advice

If your complaint is not resolved and you believe the council’s decision is unlawful, you may need legal assistance.

When to Seek Legal Help

  • If the council refuses to increase a Personal Budget, despite clear evidence that it is too low.
  • If the council is unlawfully reclaiming Direct Payments, such as applying a blanket policy instead of assessing individual needs.
  • If a complaint to the Local Government Ombudsman is unsuccessful, and legal action is required.
  • If you need to challenge the council through a judicial review.

Legal Support Options

  • Disability Law Service
    Provides free legal advice on social care and disability rights.
  • Irwin Mitchell Solicitors
    Specialises in challenging unlawful social care decisions.
  • LawWorks
    A charity that connects people with free legal support from pro bono solicitors.

 

Key Takeaways

  • Advocacy services can help you challenge Direct Payment decisions.
  • Use the council’s formal complaints process before escalating to the Ombudsman.
  • If your budget is too low or funds are being reclaimed unfairly, you can seek legal advice.
  • Connecting with other Direct Payment users can provide valuable advice and support.

 

Case Study: The Lancashire County Council Direct Payments Ruling

Case Reference: Yo Dunn v Lancashire County Council (2025)

This case was brought against Lancashire County Council by individuals receiving Direct Payments who challenged the council’s approach to reclaiming unspent funds and reducing Personal Budgets.

What Happened?

Lancashire County Council had a policy of automatically reclaiming any Direct Payment funds left unspent beyond four weeks, without considering the reasons for the unspent money. Some people had savings for planned expenses like respite care, recruitment of new personal assistants, or specialist equipment, but the council took the funds back without asking if they were still needed.

The council also cut Personal Budgets for some individuals without reassessing their care needs, arguing that they could get care for less money. People affected by these decisions argued that the cuts were unfair, as their budgets had been reduced without considering the real costs of care in their area.

What the Court Decided

The High Court ruled against Lancashire County Council, finding that their policies were unlawful under the Care Act 2014. The court made it clear that:

  • Councils cannot have blanket policies for reclaiming Direct Payments. Each case must be looked at individually.
  • Unspent Direct Payments are not automatically “surplus”—people can save money for planned care expenses.
  • Personal Budgets must be set at a level that meets assessed care needs—they cannot be reduced just to save money.
  • People must be given a fair opportunity to explain their situation before repayment demands are made.

This case confirmed that Direct Payments should remain flexible and give people control over their care, rather than being subject to rigid financial rules.

Appendix: Template Letter for Challenging an Unfair Direct Payments Repayment Request

[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[Your Postcode]
[Your Email Address]
[Your Phone Number]

[Date]

[Name of Social Worker or Council Officer]
[Council Name]
[Adult Social Care Department]
[Council Address]
[Council Postcode]

Subject: Response to Direct Payments Repayment Request

Dear [Name of Council Officer],

I am writing in response to your letter dated [insert date] requesting repayment of [insert amount] from my Direct Payments account. I am concerned that this request may not comply with the Care Act 2014 and relevant case law, including the High Court ruling in Yo Dunn v Lancashire County Council (2025). I am requesting further clarification and a formal review before any repayment is considered.

1. Legal Basis for Direct Payments and Repayment Requests

Under the Care Act 2014, Direct Payments exist to provide flexibility and control for individuals managing their care. The following legal principles must be adhered to:

  • Section 33(3), Care Act 2014 – Direct Payments must be used to meet assessed needs in accordance with the care and support plan.
  • Section 33(5), Care Act 2014 – A council may seek repayment only if a condition of the Direct Payment has been breached.
  • Care and Support Statutory Guidance, Paragraph 12.25 – Councils must ensure Direct Payments are sufficient to meet assessed needs and provide flexibility in spending.
  • Article 6, Human Rights Act 1998 – Individuals have the right to a fair hearing before any financial penalties are imposed.

Accordingly, I request that the council provide:

  • A detailed explanation of how it determined that the requested repayment is legally justified.
  • Evidence that I have breached the conditions of my Direct Payments.
  • Confirmation that I have been given a fair opportunity to present evidence and respond before this request was made.

2. Key Findings from Lancashire County Council Ruling (2025)

The High Court ruling in Yo Dunn v Lancashire County Council (2025) established that councils must follow due process when reclaiming Direct Payments. The court ruled that:

  • Blanket policies demanding repayment of funds exceeding four weeks of Direct Payments are unlawful.
  • Councils must assess individual circumstances before issuing repayment requests.
  • Any repayment request must be supported by clear evidence and provide the recipient with a fair opportunity to explain their spending.
  • Councils cannot assume that unspent funds are “surplus” without considering planned care costs.

Given this ruling, I request written confirmation that:

  • My Direct Payments have been assessed individually and not subject to an automatic repayment policy.
  • Any unspent funds have been properly reviewed in the context of my care needs and planned expenditures.

3. Challenge to the Repayment Request

Having reviewed my records, I believe that the funds in question have been allocated for necessary care costs, including:

[List any relevant planned expenses, such as personal assistant wages, respite care, equipment purchases, or pending invoices].

Therefore, I formally request that:

  • This repayment request be withdrawn or reconsidered.
  • The council conduct a full reassessment of my care needs before proceeding with any recovery action.
  • The council confirms that it has applied the principles outlined in the Lancashire County Council ruling.

4. Next Steps

I request a written response within [insert reasonable deadline, e.g., 14 or 21 days], addressing the points raised above. If I do not receive a satisfactory response, I will:

  • Challenge this request through the council’s formal complaints procedure.
  • Escalate the matter to the Local Government and Social Care Ombudsman if necessary.
  • Seek legal advice on whether this request violates my rights under the Care Act 2014 and relevant case law.

I look forward to your response. Please confirm receipt of this letter at your earliest convenience.

Yours sincerely,

[Your Full Name]
[Your Role, if applicable, e.g., Parent/Carer/Representative]