Supreme Court Judgement on Deprivation of Liberty: DSA Statement

The Down’s Syndrome Association is deeply concerned by yesterday’s Supreme Court judgment on deprivation of liberty.

For people who have Down’s syndrome, in particular individuals who have higher support needs or more limited communication, clear, enforceable safeguards are essential. The Cheshire West definition provided that clarity. It ensured that when someone was under continuous supervision and not free to leave, their situation was recognised as a deprivation of liberty, regardless of how compliant or content they appeared.

This ruling removes that certainty. It introduces the troubling suggestion that a person who lacks capacity might be seen as ‘consenting’ to restrictive arrangements simply because they seem settled. This could make it harder for families to challenge decisions that limit a person’s freedom or isolate them from family and community life, leaving people who have Down’s syndrome more exposed to inappropriate placements and restrictive environments.

We are calling for urgent clarity from Government and regulators. People who have Down’s syndrome deserve safeguards that are strong, transparent and centred on both autonomy and dignity. The DSA will continue to challenge decisions that undermine those rights and will continue to support families navigating a system that is now even more uncertain.