Down’s Syndrome Association response to the SEND and Alternative Provision White Paper

Over recent months, the Down’s Syndrome Association (DSA) has been deeply committed to engaging with the proposals set out in the Government’s Schools White Paper and SEND consultation. We are in the final stages of drafting our response. As with our work on the Down Syndrome Act guidance, our response has been shaped by two equally important sources: long‑standing professional expertise and the lived experience of parents/carers of children and young people who have Down’s syndrome.

The White Paper sets out an ambition for a more inclusive, consistent and accountable SEND system. We share that ambition. Families want a system that works early, works fairly and works lawfully, not one they must fight simply to secure basic support.

 

Listening to families

Our response to the SEND consultation is grounded in extensive engagement with families, including a series of online focus groups including under‑represented and minoritised voices and a national parent survey to gather evidence about experiences of education, as well as ongoing meetings with Department for Education officials and Ministers.

Across all this work, families that we have spoken to were clear and consistent: the SEND system does not fail because the law is unclear, or children’s needs are too complex, it fails because it is not enforced.

A group of children sit round a table in school eating packed lunches. One of the children, a boy, has Down's syndrome.

 

Inclusion, specialist provision and trust

Families spoke honestly about inclusion. Many told us they had originally hoped their child would attend mainstream school, either for some or all their education. They described how they had moved towards specialist provision only after mainstream settings lacked the expertise, confidence or support to meet their child’s needs safely and effectively. Children who have Down’s syndrome are too often diverted away from mainstream education based on assumptions rather than individual assessment. The language of ‘complex needs‘ is frequently used to lower expectations or justify exclusion before appropriate support has been attempted. As one parent put it, ‘They saw the diagnosis — not my child.‘

Equally, other parents told us that they had always chosen specialist settings for their child. They were clear that specialist provision must remain available, respected and properly resourced for children and young people who have Down’s syndrome whose needs cannot be met in mainstream, even with high levels of support. What families want is not a hierarchy of settings, but clarity: a system where provision follows need, choice is meaningful, and neither mainstream nor specialist provision is treated as a default or a failure.

It is clear that current proposals to introduce Individual Support Plans (ISPs) and Specialist Provision Packages (SPPs) alongside newly-designed EHCPs reform risk weakening protections if not designed with enforceability at their core. Parents consistently describe a system in which provision is delivered only when it is legally binding. Moving detailed, day‑to‑day provision out of EHCPs and into ISPs, without clear rights of appeal, would undermine trust and leave families without meaningful recourse.

While SPPs may have a role in helping local authorities plan and commission support, families were clear that children and young people who have Down’s syndrome must not be required to ‘fit’ into pre‑defined packages. Provision must remain individually assessed, specified and guaranteed through EHCPs, with the ability to challenge decisions through the SEND Tribunal. Without this, ISPs and SPPs risk becoming administrative tools rather than safeguards, and parents fear they would replace enforceable rights with expectations that cannot be upheld in practice.

The greatest risk to these SEND reforms is trust. Parents will not be persuaded that mainstream schools can deliver safely and consistently unless legal protections remain strong and enforceable. Inclusion cannot be built on goodwill alone.

A close up of a page of a dictionary, focusing on the word 'Trust'.

 

Rights and accountability are not the problem — they are the protection

One of the strongest messages from families was concern about proposals that would weaken or replace existing legal rights, including the role and scope of the SEND Tribunal.

Families were unequivocal: SENDIST is not the source of conflict in the system, rather it exists and is currently overwhelmed because the system so often fails to deliver what the law already requires. It is frequently the only mechanism that compels lawful decision‑making, ensures specialist evidence is taken seriously, and prevents children being pushed into unsuitable placements.

Parents described provision being delivered only when legally required, not because the system works smoothly. Weakening Tribunal powers would not reduce conflict or cost, it would remove the only effective safeguard families currently have.

A witness gives evidence at a hearing. They stand at a lectern. There are other people, sitting at tables in the background.

 

Wider barriers to inclusion

Families also highlighted broader structural and cultural barriers that must be addressed if reform is to succeed. These include:

  • weak enforcement of Equality Act 2010 duties (particularly in academies and multi‑academy trusts)
  • narrow definitions of success driven by age‑related expectations
  • curriculum models that work against inclusion
  • the marginalisation of families’ and disabled people’s voices.

Parents also raised serious concerns about inequality and intersectional disadvantage. Families from Black and minoritised communities described racial bias, cultural misunderstanding and structural inequity compounding existing SEND barriers. Without explicit recognition of these realities, reforms risk widening inequalities rather than reducing them.

A close up of someone completing an examination paper with a sharp pencil

 

What must not be overlooked

Families identified significant gaps in the White Paper, including the near‑absence of Education Otherwise Than at School (EOTAS), despite this being a statutory route for children whose needs cannot be met in school, and the limited attention given to Adult Social Care, despite its central role in preparing young people for adulthood. Wider system reorganisation, including changes to Integrated Care Boards and local authority boundaries, also risks fragmenting accountability unless explicitly addressed.

A young boy who has Down's syndrome works on school work with support from a parent/tutor

 

What families told us – a few quotes

‘The law doesn’t need replacing. It needs enforcing.’

‘If I can’t appeal it, it’s not a plan – it’s a suggestion.’

‘They saw the diagnosis – not my child.’

‘They didn’t assess what he needed – they gave him the Down’s syndrome plan.’

‘He became “too complex” the moment the school stopped adapting.’

‘My child had eight different one‑to‑one staff in a single year – that isn’t support, it’s survival.’

‘Where are these “experts at hand” supposed to come from when we’re already waiting months or years for basic support?’

‘EOTAS wasn’t what we wanted – it was what was left when school stopped being able to keep him safe.’

‘Parents aren’t fighting the system – we’re using our children’s rights to stop unlawful decisions.’

 

Our position

The DSA supports the ambition for a more inclusive and consistent SEND system. But inclusion cannot be delivered by weakening rights or asking families to place trust in systems that have repeatedly failed them.

Any reform to the SEND system must:

  • enforce existing law, including the Equality Act 2010
  • retain full SENDIST powers and enforceable EHCP provision
  • recognise both mainstream and specialist provision as valid and necessary, whilst building and enhancing mainstream inclusion
  • address intersectional disadvantage explicitly
  • rebuild trust through accountability, not aspiration.

As families told us again and again: The law does not need replacing. It needs enforcing.